Forums

GCSE Computing (OCR)

Last post 07/07/09 at 13:05 by autismuk, 15 replies
Post started by HappyHippy on 01/07/09 at 14:10

Rate this topic

Select colour:
  • Offline
    1
    Posted by: HappyHippy 01/07/2009 at 14:10
    Joined on 23/09/2005
    Posts 1,925
    Draft spec and sample assessment material now available here

    Discuss.
  • Offline
    2
    Posted by: carpentr 01/07/2009 at 14:36
    Joined on 19/04/2006
    Posts 175

     After a quick scan :

     The theory looks predictable enough - just a slightly dumbed down version of AS.

    The programming element looks straightforward enough, if perhaps a little old-fashioned - but it's hard to see how you could get round the rather basic nature of the tasks required.

    I'd be worried about the other assessment - it looks very heavy on the process of creating the report rather than the actual understanding. The specimen topic - the use of peripheral devices in your institution - is hardly stimulating.

    The controlled nature of the assessments could be a nightmare in terms of getting good quality work from the students, but it will be *much* easier for us. Indeed it looks as though we'd be redundant for large chunks of time...

    I had to chuckle at the instruction for controlled work : if the work is to be completed in more than one session, it should be collected in between the sessions. Hey, it's 1974, and they're all writing with a pen! Seriously, how you stop them working beyond the sessions I don't know. Not without running 12 hour long exams, anyway.

    It's nice to have this an an option, though!

     

     

  • Offline
    3
    Posted by: piggypiggy 01/07/2009 at 21:11
    Joined on 17/10/2004
    Posts 456

    This looks excellent. Sign me up! Solid basic theory without going over the top. Plenty of opportunity to introduce programming and basic computing knowledge. All the sh 1tty waffle that's in ICT mostly doesn't exist, which is a revelation. Finally, after all these years, OCR have got their fat *** into gear. There is a God who does perform miracles.

    The only dodgy bit I can see is the current trens assessment - that looks like waffle to me and is going to be the source of much debate between schools and OCR, not that OCR will listen of course. It's too contrived, still too easy to cheat, how you mark it is beyond me. The strange thing is that OCR haven't recognised that this is an ICT assessment not a Computing one!! They just can't get away from ICT!!!

    They were so close producing a perfect qualification that we've all been wanting, but that part aside, I would still encourage my good pupils to sign up for this than the dreadful new ICT specs or the MuppetyNationals or DiplomasForDipsticks.

  • Offline
    4
    Posted by: bainsyboy 02/07/2009 at 21:34
    Joined on 04/12/2005
    Posts 1,039

    I would love to have a go at this, but I can't see there being enough uptake at our place and we will have to continue with ICT.  Some of this will come down to it being a bit "hard" when all schools now seem to be looking for is the maximum number of points/grades, regardless of the quality of the output.  We should just give everyone an A* when the join the school, in that way everyone succeeds!

    I am quite tempted to see about running the programming bits as an extra though!!

  • Offline
    5
    Posted by: dokusu 03/07/2009 at 11:45
    Joined on 29/04/2007
    Posts 375

    It seems to be mostly OCR B in origin but without the key skills but still with two exams (why?). I'd take the time they quote for the Tasks (12 hours) with a pinch of salt and I groaned when I realised I'd have to spend more years of my life reading copious boring descriptions of input and output devices. In 2010? Is this really what ICT is about?

     

    It looks deadly dull. The examples of set tasks look the same old stuff warmed up again. I can't see many Schools rushing back to GCSE unless they they attempt to make the courses interesting and relavant to the experiences of the kids. This is not a lot further on that GCSE c 1990.

     

    OCR Nationals at least engages students. This will switch of all but the terminally dead...oh I mean would be systems analysts :-)

  • Offline
    6
    Posted by: HappyHippy 03/07/2009 at 11:53
    Joined on 23/09/2005
    Posts 1,925
    Were you looking at the Computing spec, or ICT? Also, the tasks should be 20 hours if memory serves - 8 prep and 12 'doing' (or 'writing about doing' more likely).
  • Offline
    7
    Posted by: lcfmonkey 03/07/2009 at 18:27
    Joined on 18/06/2007
    Posts 56

    piggypiggy:
    They were so close producing a perfect qualification that we've all been wanting,

    We've all been wanting this have we? Depends if you want classes of 5 kids who want to be programmers or systems analysts. I'll stick with teaching them stuff that they'll all need to know in the future

    But anyway it doesn't matter because now everyone can stop moaning about teaching ICT, put your money where your chops are and sign up to this qualification!

     

    LCFMonkey

     

    Honestly, "AND gates", pffff!

  • Offline
    8
    Posted by: 10101010 03/07/2009 at 19:28
    Joined on 14/04/2008
    Posts 43
    lcfmonkey:
    Depends if you want classes of 5 kids who want to be programmers or systems analysts. qualification!

    Honestly, "AND gates", pffff!

    I'm pretty confident that we could sign up a class of 15-20 for this already, without any Key Stage 3 introduction other than using Scratch. Not everyone will become a programmer or a systems analyst, but they might well enjoy the problem solving and mathematical dimension. I had to study R.E. at school, but I didn't become a vicar. Do you not think that your computer or it's software has a use for AND gates then? This GCSE looks like a nice introduction - not the be-all-and-end-all, not a degree - it starts students off in roughly the right direction (although people are free to choose an alternative direction if they like).
  • Offline
    9
    Posted by: lcfmonkey 04/07/2009 at 23:35
    Joined on 18/06/2007
    Posts 56

    10101010:
    I had to study R.E. at school, but I didn't become a vicar.

     

    I really should know better than posting on a Friday night when I'm all tired and hot. I was being arsey because I attended a GCSE specification meeting recently which was hijacked by moaners groaning on about how much they hated teaching ICT, that "Pearson owning Edexcel was a concern" and that mentioning Google in lessons was promoting Microsoft!!

    By the way I love your quote and you are quite right, it's not only analysts and programmers that will do the course!

    Amazing was a sunny saturday can do to one's attitude!!

  • Offline
    10
    Posted by: johncollinswork 06/07/2009 at 15:45
    Joined on 19/06/2005
    Posts 224

    This looks good, but I am curious as to what software it would be delivered in?

    Visual Basic would be my choice, any other ideas?

Back to top

Sign up – it’s free!

  • Don’t miss out on the latest jobs
  • Connect and share with friends
  • Download thousands of resources
  • Chat in the forums