Forums

A positive MFL story

Last post 02/07/09 at 16:43 by charmedimsure, 13 replies
Post started by charmedimsure on 26/06/09 at 09:36

Rate this topic

Select colour:
  • Offline
    1
    Posted by: charmedimsure 26/06/2009 at 09:36
    Joined on 16/04/2007
    Posts 237

    I have twin sons in yr 7. One has Aspergers and struggles in many subjects. It was suggested when he started yr 7 that perhaps he should come out of German to concentrate on his literacy and numeracy skills. I said no as I wanted him to have a chance and he was basically starting at the same level as everybody else. Yesterday he came home with a note in his organiser to say that he had scored the top mark in his year in the German writing test! I am so proud of him as he has worked very hard. This is the first time he has ever come top in anything or 'beaten' his brother. His teacher sent me an e-mail to say how much he deserved this and how wonderful it was to see the surprise on so many of his classmate's faces. For all of those pupils who struggle in English and it is suggested that it is best to drop a MFL, he has proved them wrong.

  • Offline
    2
    Posted by: Dodros 26/06/2009 at 09:55
    Joined on 28/03/2005
    Posts 1,762

    This is indeed excellent news, charmedimsure. Good for you, insisting your son stays in MFL and I'm delighted you have been proved right. Please convey my congratulations to him.

    As a retired MFL and SEN teacher, I've known of several cases where students with SEN end up performing far better in MFL than they do in English. In my own school, Year 7s with literacy and/or numeracy problems are pulled out of morning registration two or three times a week for catch-up classes, not out of foundation subjects where they have the potential to shine, and the vast majority make good progress in reading, writing and basic Maths during these sessions run before timetabled lessons begin.

  • Offline
    3
    Posted by: sam enerve 26/06/2009 at 11:31
    Joined on 21/06/2007
    Posts 1,873

    That is excellent news indeed charmedimsure. Please pass my congratulations on as well.

    I have a student in Year 9 with aspergers and he is achieving as well, if not better, in German as he is in his other subjects (with the exception of maths in which he is frighteningly good!). German is his favourite subject but, sadly, he has not been allowed to choose it as an option in KS4.

    sam

  • Offline
    4
    Posted by: charmedimsure 26/06/2009 at 15:18
    Joined on 16/04/2007
    Posts 237

    Thank you both for your good wishes. Sam it is a real shame that your student in yr 9 is not allowed to choose German as an option. I hope by the time my son gets to yr 9 it will still be offered. I would like to write to the school to express my thanks to the teacher who has been very understanding in the way she has taught and supported my son. As she is the subject leader for MFL could you suggest who I should write to.

    Dodros, school started to take my son out of a variety of lessons which basically meant that he would eventually become even more behind in all of them. As expected most teachers were not happy with this, neither was he. He attends various support sessions before school, at lunchtime and occasionally during tutorial, so he is working double hard than most.

  • Offline
    5
    Posted by: Geekie 26/06/2009 at 15:25
    Joined on 03/08/2005
    Posts 4,113

    I have a lad with Aspergers in my Y10 Spanish group.  He has excellent recall compared to the rest of them, and his encyclopaedic knowledge of countries and flags comes in handy !

  • Offline
    6
    Posted by: mpc 26/06/2009 at 18:15
    Joined on 03/04/2007
    Posts 1,795

    Write to the head (or if you prefer, the COG) copying the teacher on your email. 

    Very pleased to read your good news story!

    mpc Big Smile

  • Offline
    7
    Posted by: Pippi Langstrumpf 26/06/2009 at 20:46
    Joined on 30/01/2007
    Posts 133

    I've taught German to a year 11 boy with Aspergers this year, he was a joy to teach, loves German and wishes he hadn't dropped French. I've predicted he'll get one of the highest grades in his class and he's going on to do German at A-Level.  

  • Offline
    8
    Posted by: HelenMyers 28/06/2009 at 10:35
    Joined on 29/03/2005
    Posts 794

    Great to read a good news story. Thanks for this charmedimsure. 

    It would be nice if it could reach an even wider audience including non ml teachers who may have to be 'fighting their corner'.  I shall certainly be using it as an 'anecdote'.  If you don't mind being quoted as a 'real person' (you know what I mean ...!), please could you get in touch with me off forum (I ask this because my own inbox on this site is unreliable .. something to do wuth th eold version of IE I'm using I think...), and I think this would be a nice letter / article for an ALL publication (perhaps the new magazine) .. then teachers can have something to show their managers / colleagues.  My school e mail : myers dot helen at ashcombe dot surrey dot sch dot uk

  • Offline
    9
    Posted by: Dodros 28/06/2009 at 12:01
    Joined on 28/03/2005
    Posts 1,762

    I agree, Helen, a story that deserves the widest possible audience!

    Not many people may be aware of the fact, but the UK probably leads the world when it comes to conducting research and developing good practice in teaching MFL to students with autistic spectrum disorders (ASD), which include Asperger Syndrome. Between 2002 and 2005, Scottish expert Vivienne Wire began writing groundbreaking articles on the subject of MFL for ASD. For an overview see:

    http://www.hilarymccoll.co.uk/autismMFL.html

    In 2004 the Department for Education and Skills and the North West Regional Special Educational Needs Partnership published a booklet entitled "Children with autism: strategies for accessing the curriculum: modern foreign languages", which can be downloaded from

    http://www.teachernet.gov.uk/_doc/6701/modern%20foreign%20languages.pdf

    Germany, which is a world-class leader in special educational needs provision and whose categories of SEN usually mirror ours, doesn't appear to have special schools or units for ASD and even after exhaustive searches I've never managed to locate any professional literature in German about the teaching of MFL to students with ASD in Germany.

    Only in the last year or so has some interest developed abroad in MFL for ASD, notably Christine Besnard of York University in the Canadian city of Toronto, who has made several presentations since 2007 on the subject of foreign language learners with Asperger Syndrome. One of her handouts is on the Web at

    http://www.cmcgc.com/Media/HANDOUTS/081022/070.pdf
     

     

  • Offline
    10
    Posted by: HelenMyers 28/06/2009 at 19:47
    Joined on 29/03/2005
    Posts 794

    mmm ... just had a thought about who could be interviewed for another edition ...!!!!

    I'll be in touch ...

Back to top

Sign up – it’s free!

  • Don’t miss out on the latest jobs
  • Connect and share with friends
  • Download thousands of resources
  • Chat in the forums