Forums

Worksheet-free school

Last post 26/02/12 at 10:33 by mfoden, 74 replies
Post started by choca_holic on 11/02/12 at 13:25

Rate this topic

Select colour:
  • Offline
    1
    Posted by: choca_holic 11/02/2012 at 13:25
    Joined on 03/04/2011
    Posts 72

    Hi,

    A school near me is advertising for a teacher, and they say they are a worksheet-free school. This sounds great in theory, but does anyone have any experience of this in practise? Does it make planning more difficult, as you can rarely use things downloaded from websites such as TES and primaryresources.co.uk?

    Don't get me wrong, I by no means teach in a death-by-worksheet fashion, but sometimes they are a good way of practising a skill or assessing understanding. Do such schools have a similarly negative approach to textbooks? Often there is little difference between working through a couple of pages in a textbook and working though a worksheet, but a worksheet is more customisable/easily differentiated.

    The job seems great, but I would love to hear some people's experiences of planning and teaching in a completely worksheet-free zone.

    Thanks in advance for any replies!

  • Offline
    2
    Posted by: RJR_38 11/02/2012 at 13:33
    Joined on 11/05/2005
    Posts 3,701

    Personally I would avoid it like the plague. Saying you are 'work-sheet free' is a huge generalisation and can lead to very poor teaching standards in my opinion. By all means, ban 'photocopied out of a book, 1 sheet does all' type things but a worksheet made by the teacher specifically for a child or a group of children can be a great teaching tool.

     I am a huge fan of practical, hands on teaching and would say that the majority of my teaching is this way - however, there are times when worksheets are appropriate. No one teaching method should ever be banned completley imo - everything in moderation.

  • Offline
    3
    Posted by: choca_holic 11/02/2012 at 13:40
    Joined on 03/04/2011
    Posts 72

    Thanks RJR, an interesting response similar to what I was thinking.

    My other concern is evidence. It seems everyone is obsessed with keeping 'evidence' of the learning that has taken place in case OFSTED turn up. In subjects such as maths you can be as practical and creative as you like, but surely some things need to be written down to prove they have been covered, and answering questions from the board, textbook or worksheet is all much of a muchness.

    Would be really interested in other people's thoughts...

  • Offline
    4
    Posted by: jojojohns 11/02/2012 at 15:07
    Joined on 07/02/2012
    Posts 1

     Sounds like a head with a bee in their bonnet. Any explanation as to why? Is there an educational rationale behind this?

     Or is is simply to save on photocopying costs..?.

  • Offline
    5
    Posted by: minnieminx 11/02/2012 at 15:11
    Joined on 06/03/2006
    Posts 8,117
    I'd suggest going to visit and having a look around at displays and books. See what is there. If you see massive piles of dull textbooks in every classroom, then you might want to worry. If not then I'd be applying ASAP.

    Sounds like my kind of place. Although I do use worksheets sometimes, I'd love to find a way to never do so. I've never seen the real benefit of a sheet over a textbook / questions on the board / dictated work / any other written bits. I use them mainly when I can't think of something else.

  • Offline
    6
    Posted by: debbiehep 11/02/2012 at 15:51
    Joined on 20/05/2003
    Posts 3,792

    I find it very worrying that there is an apparent rising anti-worksheet culture.

    Like anything else in education, teachers should be able to evaluate any medium through which we teach pupils and through which pupils learn.

    Thus, a 'worksheet' needs to be evaluated for its role - and into this consideration is whether any other medium is more fit for purpose, more value for money - or whatever.

    I think a 'worksheet' which is a simple piece of paper (and can be readily photocopied or printed) can be an ideal medium to give individual children (including the same sheet for the whole class where this is appropriate) when it includes information and/or includes appropriate activities to support teaching and learning.

    Further, the pupil can keep ownership of it, can take it home, can build up his or her own work, and can refer to it for revision - or even pride if it tracks/monitors progress or supports a programme of work.

    I could go on - but certainly with not much thought, suddenly the advantages can start to become clear.

    The trouble is, how much thought do teachers give to the 'worksheet' approach over and above just dismissing because it seems to be the current trend for some teachers/schools.

  • Offline
    7
    Posted by: debbiehep 11/02/2012 at 15:57
    Joined on 20/05/2003
    Posts 3,792

    I tried to edit the above post but my edit went into the ether!

    Much of what pupils do nowadays seems so temporary. The game or activity comes to an end, the machine is switched off or another programme takes over, the whiteboard is wiped clean - and so on.

  • Offline
    8
    Posted by: minnieminx 11/02/2012 at 16:58
    Joined on 06/03/2006
    Posts 8,117
    But all the advantages of ownership and longevity can easily be achieved with work in an exercise book. Questions on a board or from a textbook give all the same possibilities.

    I totally agree that some work needs to be written and that a sense of pride in one's work is definitely a good thing, but this does not make a worksheet necessary.

  • Offline
    9
    Posted by: debbiehep 12/02/2012 at 00:19
    Joined on 20/05/2003
    Posts 3,792

    I think exercise books are great too and have advantages - but they are 'empty' and cannot supply content or direct activities for the learners to do.

    It is too much of a generalisation to use the term 'worksheet' which has become a derogatory term for many teachers.

    Perhaps teachers need to think of 'fit-for-purpose' methods and materials and not be so quick to dismiss 'worksheets' which can be a very convenient and effective method and medium for both teaching and learning purposes -and for informing parents where this might be an advantage.

  • Offline
    10
    Posted by: RaggyBull 12/02/2012 at 09:19
    Joined on 29/11/2006
    Posts 24

    I think it's fair enough to avoid worksheets as much as possible, but for some maths topics they are useful. Reading different scales and times, fractions of shapes or reflection/symmetry questions are good examples of where worksheets of differentiated examples are very useful. I think most teachers will adapt resources (like those found on this website) to suit their class.

    When all said and done, we assess children by using what essentially are worksheets stapled together in the form of a test.

Back to top

Sign up – it’s free!

  • Don’t miss out on the latest jobs
  • Connect and share with friends
  • Download thousands of resources
  • Chat in the forums