TESthink, educate, share

macbook pro or air?

Avatar

TES Scotland opinion - Forum

This is where Scottish teachers go to let off some steam. Join the debate in the Scotland Opinion Group and chat about the key issues affecting education in Scotland.

Members 1010 Total Posts 15569

macbook pro or air?

  • post reply
    • I'm about to buy a new laptop and am an absolute Apple fan. However, I'm not sure which suits me better. What are my main wishes?

      I occasionaly help my neighbour's children with a little extra work and so accessing the internet for resources is a must. I want WORD so that I can make up worksheets/docs etc. I like to download music & photographs. I want BBC iPlayer etc. I want to be able to play CDs & DVDs. Which external drive would be best? (It's a shame that's no longer built in.)

       Thank you for any advice. 

      (Have posted this on other forums too.)
    <div> <img src="//secure-uk.imrworldwide.com/cgi-bin/m?ci=uk-405391h&cg=0&cc=1&ts=noscript" width="1" height="1" alt="" /></div>
    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply
    I went for a Pro last month for two reasons. 1) I wanted one with a 13" screen - the basic 13" Air is £999 and the basic 13" Pro was the same price. 2) A dvd/cd drive is pretty important to me in a laptop and the Air doesn't come with one. I didn't want to pay £999 for a laptop that didn't have a cd/dvd drive and then have to pay £65 for an external drive... I obviously bought it through the Apple Store for Education though for the discount and I also got a £70 voucher for iTunes/App Store with it for free. It's a fantastic machine.
    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply

    mossop
    the Air doesn't come with one. I didn't want to pay £999 for a laptop that didn't have a cd/dvd drive and then have to pay £65 for an external drive...

     

     Thanks for advice, Mossop. Much apppreciated. I was under the impression that the new pros and airs don't have an in-built cd/dvd drive. 

    Still unclear about pro/air differences. I'm not a computer buff by any stretch...

    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply
    The Pros do come with a built in drive. This is a link to the Pro spec, and this is the Air spec. I personally think the Pro is better value for money for what you get and found the 11" screen on the basic Air is too small. I also have a 3 year old, so the Air just felt a bit flimsy, although it is a lovely looking machine. You'll no doubt get someone come along and tell you to buy a Windows machine, and to be fair, you'll get much more for your money with a Windows machine, but I switched to Mac 5 years ago and have never regretted it. The last Macbook I had lasted 4 and a half years (and apart from the battery life, it's still going strong really - I just decided it was time for an upgrade!) which is 3 times longer than any Windows machine I've owned so was better value for money for me in the long run.
    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply

     Thanks very much, mossop. I was under the misapprehension that the pros didn't have a built-in CD/DVD drive. 

    mossop
    The last Macbook I had lasted 4 and a half years (and apart from the battery life, it's still going strong really - I just decided it was time for an upgrade!) which is 3 times longer than any Windows machine I've owned so was better value for money for me in the long run.

    I totally agree, as my iBook has lasted nearly 7 years with only one upgrade. Friends are on their 3rd pc since then! 

    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply

    my2leftfeet
    I was under the impression that the new pros and airs don't have an in-built cd/dvd drive.

    Actually, you're sort of right. The very newest MacBook Pro (the Retina one) and all MacBook Airs don't have a DVD drive built in. The other current models, however, do.

    MacBooks with a DVD drive:

    • MacBook Pro 13"
    • MacBook Pro 15"

    MacBooks without a DVD drive:

    • MacBook Pro with Retina Display
    • MacBook Air

    Any Mac on the market would meet your needs, but it sounds to me like you want a regular MacBook Pro, as it has a DVD drive. To justify the extra relative cost of the other models (not to mention the lack of a built-inDVD drive), you'd have to really need the graphics for a Retina MacBook or the lightness and portability of a MacBook Air.

    Personally, I have an iMac, as I don't need portability.

    It's certainly worth going into a shop and playing with the different sized models of the regular MacBook Pros to see which suits you the most. Obviously, then buy it online with the Education discount!

    Also check if your school's licensing agreement with Microsoft allows you to purchase Office cheaply through them. My school's does and it's under a tenner. If not, you're looking at full price for the Home and Student Edition (about £80). There used to be an Academic Edition that was the Pro version with a £30-ish price tag, but that's now been replaced by a University Edition that is not available to teachers.

     



    [edited by: CandysDog at 22:11 (GMT 0) on 13-8-2012]
    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply
  • post reply
    I just use Open Office for Mac - it's free and does the job nicely!
    Posted
    Please join this group to replyReply